
Premier League Points vs Odds-Expected Points: Club by Club
Club by club, I compare Premier League points with what closing 1X2 odds expected, then test whether beating or missing the market carries into the next season.
Every price on a 1X2 market carries an implied number of points. Add those up across a club's matches and you get odds-expected points, which is what the market thought a side would collect before a ball was kicked. The question here is simple. Which Premier League clubs have beaten that figure, which have fallen short, and does the gap last long enough to matter for betting?
The short answer is that the gaps are real in hindsight but close to useless as a forecast. Over a window of 1,900 matches, Aston Villa sit on +35.6 against their odds and Chelsea on โ35.6. Yet across 68 consecutive-season cases, the sign of the gap repeated only 47.1% of the time. If you follow my football 1X2 tips page, this is why I treat a club's recent luck against the market as noise rather than signal.
Section AAston Villa and Arsenal top the table, Chelsea and Southampton trail
This chart shows each club's points minus its odds-expected points from 2021/22 to 2025/26. Aston Villa lead on +35.6 from 190 matches. Arsenal follow on +29.1, and Fulham are on +22.1 from 152 matches. At the other end, Chelsea sit on โ35.6 and Southampton on โ33.8, the latter from just 114 matches.
View the data: premier league: points minus odds-expected points
| Points above expected | |
|---|---|
| Aston Villa (190) | +35.6 pts |
| Arsenal (190) | +29.1 pts |
| Fulham (152) | +22.1 pts |
| Brentford (190) | +19.8 pts |
| Bournemouth (152) | +18.2 pts |
| Nottingham Forest (152) | +13.1 pts |
| Crystal Palace (190) | +12.6 pts |
| Newcastle (190) | +12.4 pts |
| West Ham (190) | โ2.7 pts |
| Wolves (190) | โ4.6 pts |
| Leicester (114) | โ13.1 pts |
| Tottenham (190) | โ13.4 pts |
| Leeds (114) | โ16 pts |
| Burnley (114) | โ20.8 pts |
| Southampton (114) | โ33.8 pts |
| Chelsea (190) | โ35.6 pts |
Be clear about what the gap measures. Closing odds already include team news and form, so a positive number means a club beat the market's view on the day, not that it is secretly better than people think. A total of around ยฑ10 points over five seasons is still a small sample, so most of the middle of this chart is noise.
Section BFourteen ever-present Premier League clubs show how small most gaps are
Restricting the comparison to the 14 clubs present in all five seasons makes it fairer. The per-38-games column turns each total into an average season. Aston Villa come out at +7.1 and Chelsea at โ7.1, with Arsenal on +5.8. Most of the rest sit close to zero: Manchester City on +0.6, Manchester United on +0.3 and Liverpool on โ0.4.
| Club | Matches | Points | Expected | Gap | Per 38 games |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aston Villa | 190 | 305 | 269.4 | +35.6 | +7.1 |
| Arsenal | 190 | 401 | 371.9 | +29.1 | +5.8 |
| Brentford | 190 | 253 | 233.2 | +19.8 | +4.0 |
| Crystal Palace | 190 | 240 | 227.4 | +12.6 | +2.5 |
| Newcastle | 190 | 295 | 282.6 | +12.4 | +2.5 |
| Manchester City | 190 | 422 | 419.0 | +3.0 | +0.6 |
| Manchester United | 190 | 306 | 304.3 | +1.7 | +0.3 |
| Brighton | 190 | 275 | 276.5 | โ1.5 | โ0.3 |
| Liverpool | 190 | 385 | 387.0 | โ2.0 | โ0.4 |
| Everton | 190 | 220 | 222.1 | โ2.1 | โ0.4 |
| West Ham | 190 | 230 | 232.7 | โ2.7 | โ0.5 |
| Wolves | 190 | 200 | 204.6 | โ4.6 | โ0.9 |
| Tottenham | 190 | 276 | 289.4 | โ13.4 | โ2.7 |
| Chelsea | 190 | 302 | 337.6 | โ35.6 | โ7.1 |
That cluster near zero is what a well-calibrated market looks like. For most of the big clubs, the closing price has matched their points almost exactly over five years. That is the baseline I assume until the evidence says otherwise.
Section CAston Villa versus Chelsea, season by season against the market
The totals hide how each club got there. Villa started at โ3.6 in 2021/22, then ran at +12.0, +9.7, +7.5 and +10.0. Chelsea went from โ19.5 to โ0.6 to +0.6 and back to โ12.4, which looks less like a trait and more like a string of separate seasons.
The wider numbers support that reading. Across 68 cases of a club playing consecutive seasons, the season-to-season correlation of the gap was 0.01. Of the 14 ever-presents, none finished above expectation in all five seasons and none finished below it in all five. Even among 20 club-seasons that finished 5 or more points above expectation, only 55.0% were above it again the next season.
View the data: season by season: aston villa vs chelsea
| Aston Villa | Chelsea | |
|---|---|---|
| 2021/22 | โ3.6 pts | โ3.5 pts |
| 2022/23 | 12 pts | โ19.5 pts |
| 2023/24 | 9.7 pts | โ0.6 pts |
| 2024/25 | 7.5 pts | 0.6 pts |
| 2025/26 | 10 pts | โ12.4 pts |
Villa's run is the closest thing to persistence in this data, and I wouldn't dismiss it. But a single club standing out in a full division is exactly what chance produces, so I hold that view loosely.
Section DSunderland, Manchester United and Wolves posted the widest 2025/26 gaps
The dumbbell chart shows the eight clubs furthest from their expected total in 2025/26. Sunderland took 54 points against 38.7 expected, a gap of +15.3, and finished 7th. Manchester United reached 71 against 60.9 expected. Going the other way, Wolves took 20 points from 33.5 expected, Chelsea managed 52 against 64.4, and Liverpool finished on 60 against 70.1.
View the data: 2025/26: the biggest gaps to odds-expected points
| Odds-expected | Actual points | |
|---|---|---|
| Manchester United (finished 3rd) | 60.9 pts | 71 pts |
| Aston Villa (finished 4th) | 55 pts | 65 pts |
| Liverpool (finished 5th) | 70.1 pts | 60 pts |
| Sunderland (finished 7th) | 38.7 pts | 54 pts |
| Chelsea (finished 10th) | 64.4 pts | 52 pts |
| Newcastle (finished 12th) | 58.5 pts | 49 pts |
| Tottenham (finished 17th) | 51 pts | 41 pts |
| Wolves (finished 20th) | 33.5 pts | 20 pts |
This is the chart most likely to mislead. A side that beats its odds by that margin invites the assumption that the market underrated it. The persistence figures say the following season starts close to a coin flip on direction.
Club verdict
What this file means before you bet.
- Price each season fresh. Last season's gap tells you very little about the next one, because the sign repeated 47.1% of the time. Don't back Sunderland or oppose Wolves just because of their 2025/26 numbers.
- Respect Villa, but cautiously. Aston Villa have beaten their odds every season since 2021/22 and average +7.1 per 38 games, the strongest record here. Treat it as a mild lean to check against the price, not an edge, because club samples are small.
- Don't fade Chelsea blindly. Chelsea's โ35.6 came mostly from two poor seasons, with near-zero gaps in between. Their closing prices already reflect who is fit and in form at kick-off.
Frequently asked
Which Premier League club has most outperformed its betting odds?
Aston Villa took 305 points from 190 matches between 2021/22 and 2025/26, against the 269.4 their pre-match odds implied. That is a gap of +35.6, level with Chelsea's shortfall as the largest in the study.
Do teams that beat their expected points keep doing it?
Not reliably. Across 68 consecutive-season cases, the sign of the gap repeated 47.1% of the time and the correlation was 0.01. Even strong overperformers were above expectation again only 55.0% of the time.
How far did Chelsea fall short of their odds?
Chelsea took 302 points against 337.6 odds-expected points over five seasons, a gap of โ35.6. That works out to โ7.1 points per 38 games, the worst average among the ever-present clubs.
