
Biggest Elo Fallers in Europe's Top Flights Since 2016
Ten seasons of Elo ratings show which 2016/17 top-flight clubs lost the most ground. The list mixes relegated sides with two of Spain's biggest names.
Which clubs that played in a European top flight in 2016/17 have lost the most Elo rating since? I tracked 196 clubs across 11 top flights. Of those, 159 have a rating at both ends of the ten seasons, and 74 of them finished lower than they started.
The headline answer is Leicester, down 334 points. Stoke, Nancy, Granada and Sporting Gijón follow. I use ratings like these as a starting input before my simulations produce the probabilities behind my free 1X2 picks page, so a long, steady decline is something I want to understand rather than simply record.
Section ALeicester top a faller list dominated by Spanish clubs
The bars rank clubs by Elo points lost from their first league match of 2016/17 to their last of 2025/26. Leicester stand well clear on 334, with Stoke on 239 and Nancy and Granada tied on 211. In this rating, about 100 points is a clear gap between two sides, so Leicester's fall is several of those gaps stacked together.
View the data: biggest elo falls since the start of 2016/17
| Clubs in a European top flight in 2016/17; Elo points lost to the end of 2025/26 | |
|---|---|
| Leicester | 334 |
| Stoke | 239 |
| Nancy | 211 |
| Granada | 211 |
| Sporting Gijón | 205 |
| Málaga | 200 |
| Pescara | 188 |
| Atlético Madrid | 187 |
| Sevilla | 183 |
| Leganés | 180 |
| Schalke | 175 |
| Southampton | 171 |
| Swansea | 169 |
| Bastia | 167 |
| Watford | 161 |
| Athletic Bilbao | 160 |
Spain supplies Granada, Sporting Gijón, Málaga, Leganés, Atlético Madrid, Sevilla and Athletic Bilbao. The Spanish clubs that stayed in La Liga matter most to me here. Atlético dropped 187 and Sevilla 183 without leaving the division, and that points to a real change in level rather than a drop that came mainly from relegation.
Section BAtlético Madrid and Sevilla fell without being relegated
The table sets each club's rating and division then against its rating and division now. Most of the top ten moved down a level: Leicester and Stoke to the Championship, Nancy to Ligue 2, Pescara to Serie B, and Granada, Sporting Gijón, Málaga and Leganés to the Segunda División.
Atlético Madrid went from 2,004 to 1,817 and are still in La Liga. Sevilla went from 1,823 to 1,640 and are also still there. Real Madrid are outside this top ten, but they slipped too, from 2,077 to 1,921, a change of −156.
| Club | Start | Division then | End | Division now | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leicester | 1,813 | Premier League | 1,479 | Championship | −334 |
| Stoke | 1,683 | Premier League | 1,444 | Championship | −239 |
| Nancy | 1,541 | Ligue 1 | 1,330 | Ligue 2 | −211 |
| Granada | 1,691 | La Liga | 1,480 | Segunda División | −211 |
| Sporting Gijón | 1,696 | La Liga | 1,491 | Segunda División | −205 |
| Málaga | 1,756 | La Liga | 1,556 | Segunda División | −200 |
| Pescara | 1,533 | Serie A | 1,345 | Serie B | −188 |
| Atlético Madrid | 2,004 | La Liga | 1,817 | La Liga | −187 |
| Sevilla | 1,823 | La Liga | 1,640 | La Liga | −183 |
| Leganés | 1,648 | La Liga | 1,468 | Segunda División | −180 |
Ratings carry league strength, so relegation lowers a club's number over time almost by itself. That is the main caveat I would attach to the relegated names. For clubs that stayed up, the decline is a cleaner signal, and the market's picture of them may have been built when they were stronger.
Section CLeicester's slide was late, while Stoke and Nancy fell early
This chart follows the season-end rating of the three biggest fallers. Leicester finished 2016/17 on 1,733, then held up and rose for several seasons, peaking in 2020/21 slightly above where they had started. Most of their fall came in the last few seasons, ending on 1,479 in 2025/26.
View the data: season-end elo of the three biggest fallers
| Leicester | Stoke | Nancy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016/17 | 1,732.8 | 1,648.1 | 1,512.4 |
| 2017/18 | 1,705 | 1,631.2 | 1,389.6 |
| 2018/19 | 1,729.2 | 1,511.1 | 1,379 |
| 2019/20 | 1,779.4 | 1,476.3 | 1,371.2 |
| 2020/21 | 1,819.6 | 1,491.5 | 1,388 |
| 2021/22 | 1,759.5 | 1,510.7 | 1,287.3 |
| 2022/23 | 1,709.2 | 1,494.2 | – |
| 2023/24 | 1,674.1 | 1,455.1 | – |
| 2024/25 | 1,611.1 | 1,464.2 | – |
| 2025/26 | 1,478.5 | 1,443.8 | 1,329.6 |
Stoke went the other way. They finished 2016/17 on 1,648, lost most of their ground within two seasons, then levelled off and ended on 1,444. Nancy fell early from 1,512, then disappear from the line for three seasons while they were outside the covered divisions, and return on 1,330. The way a club falls tells me more than the size of the fall: a steady drift and a sudden collapse call for different handling in a model.
Section DBundesliga and Eredivisie line-ups held together, Greece's did not
The stacked bars show where each league's 2016/17 clubs played in 2025/26. Overall, 128 of 196 were in the same top flight, 32 were in a lower covered division and 36 were outside the divisions covered. The Bundesliga and Eredivisie kept the most, with 14 of 18 clubs (77.8%) still there. Super League Greece kept the fewest, 9 of 16 (56.2%), and 7 of its clubs are no longer in a covered division.
View the data: where 2016/17 top-flight clubs played in 2025/26
| Same top flight | Lower covered division | Not in covered divisions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League (20) | 60.0% | 40.0% | 0.0% |
| La Liga (20) | 65.0% | 35.0% | 0.0% |
| Serie A (20) | 70.0% | 20.0% | 10.0% |
| Bundesliga (18) | 77.8% | 16.7% | 5.6% |
| Ligue 1 (20) | 60.0% | 25.0% | 15.0% |
| Scottish Premiership (12) | 58.3% | 41.7% | 0.0% |
| Primeira Liga (18) | 61.1% | 0.0% | 38.9% |
| Eredivisie (18) | 77.8% | 0.0% | 22.2% |
| Belgian Pro League (16) | 62.5% | 0.0% | 37.5% |
| Süper Lig (18) | 66.7% | 0.0% | 33.3% |
| Super League Greece (16) | 56.2% | 0.0% | 43.8% |
This chart also shows the limit of the ranking. Portugal, the Netherlands, Belgium, Turkey and Greece have no second tier in the data, and clubs such as Bordeaux, Chievo and Vitesse dropped out of the covered divisions altogether. The steepest falls in this period are probably among those clubs, and I cannot rate them, so the faller list covers only clubs that stayed inside the measured leagues.
Club verdict
What this file means before you bet.
- Rate Atlético and Sevilla fresh. Atlético Madrid lost 187 points and Sevilla 183 while staying in La Liga. When they are priced, judge them on their current level rather than their reputation from 2016/17.
- Read Leicester's trend, not history. Leicester finished 2016/17 on 1,733 and 2025/26 on 1,479, with most of the drop coming late. A recent slide like that may not yet be fully reflected in public perception, though one club's path is a small sample to build on.
- Discount relegation-driven drops. Ratings carry league strength, so relegated clubs such as Stoke, Granada and Pescara lose points partly from the level they play at. Compare them with their current division rather than with their old top-flight number.
Frequently asked
Which European top-flight club has lost the most Elo since 2016/17?
Leicester, who fell from 1,813 at the start of 2016/17 to 1,479 at the end of 2025/26, a drop of 334 points. Stoke are second with a fall of 239.
How many 2016/17 top-flight clubs are still in the same league?
128 of the 196 clubs in the 11 top flights were in the same top flight in 2025/26. Another 32 were in a lower covered division and 36 were outside the covered divisions.
Have Real Madrid's and Atlético Madrid's Elo ratings dropped?
Yes. Real Madrid went from 2,077 to 1,921, a change of −156, and Atlético Madrid from 2,004 to 1,817, a change of −187, with both staying in La Liga throughout.
